Sunday, 4 October 2009

Interpersonal Relationship

Last month, the movie UP by Disney Pixar ended its run in cinemas and my favourite part was the love story between the old man Carl Fredricksen and his wife, Ellie as I am unable to put in the clip of the movie here as the DVD of the movie is not up yet. Here's the write up of their love story.
Carl's quiet and sort of shy, but his love of Muntz leads him to Ellie, a sassy little girl who is as outgoing as Carl is introverted. They make for a great team and in fact will go on to share their lives together. From elementary school through high school and on up into adulthood, Carl and Ellie are inseparable, sharing every moment of joy and sadness together while dreaming of a time when they can actually take off on an adventure in the wilds of South America just like their hero, Muntz. But jobs and health issues and whatnot have a way of intruding on dreams, and Carl and Ellie grow old never having visited the South American jungles. And then, sadly, Carl becomes a widower with just his lovely little house and his beautiful memories of Ellie to keep him company.

you could check out their official site or read up the full synopsis by clicking on the respective.

Though it was just a short section of the movie , I could see how their relationship was built up. Their relational formation and development could be due to

1. Dissimilarities and similarities : Carl would always listen to Ellie talk about her dreams and everything she had to share, he would always lend a listening ear to her. While Ellie , being the outgoing one would encourage him to do things that he would love to do but probably would not have the courage to do so. Despite their opposing characters , they were drawn together by a common dream as mentioned in the write up above. They were thus brought together by their complementary differences , their social preference similarity and attitudinal similarity where they shared a similar social activity and had a preference for adventure.

2. Proximity : Living in the same neighborhood gave them more opportunities for interaction

When they eventually got married , I was able to see their relational maintenance where they met each other’s relational needs. For example in the short run , Carl would help Ellie around the house , they encouraging each other on as they worked together and when they got older , Carl would help Ellie up the hill where they always had picnics , taking care of her when she fell ill. In the long run , they worked together to fulfill their dream as they made a joint effort to save up in hope that they could go to South America.
So which was the key to their relationship formation , similarities, disimilaritites or proximity?
To me , I feel their opposing characters was the key while their similar dream and proximity just made everything easier. Having dissimilarities allowed them to support each other and make up for each other's weaknesses and needs. If they had similar characters and similar dreams , they would not have needed each other to remind and help each other out they could have just done everything themselves and they probably would not even be attracted to each other as they each have what the other had. For example , if they were both talkative then there would be nobody to listen. Thus , dissimilarities is the most important component here.




7 comments:

  1. i love the movie UP!!! :) well, i feel that this movie is a good example to show the stages of how the relationship was built up.

    dissimilarities may be good, but it have its bad points too. this must be noted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think relation formation is one of the most complex of processes in humanity--it involves so many categories and stages! This UP movie is very cute. I saw a clip of it on my friend's blog, and it made me really want to watch it. In a way, it seems to portray the most ideal, sweetest scenario of relation formation, to the point where it seems too good to be true. I think so at least.

    What do you think?(:

    ReplyDelete
  3. I did not manage to watch this movie :( But I heard that it's really good!

    I feel that dissimilarities are not all that matters, nor is it the most important factor in relationship formation. At the initial stage, I still feel that it'd be more gratifying to find someone who is similar to you. In terms of aspiration, and perhaps even character. These factors help to affirm our social selves, and give us a greater confidence in ourselves since we know other the significant other who is in support of your character and even aspirations.

    However when the relationship develops further, dissimilarities would then be important to keep the relationship exciting and refreshing. There could be potential surprises when two people express their love differently (that's a dissimilarity, isn't it?).

    Moreover, it is highly possible to decipher wrong messages when two people are too dissimilar. They will tend to misread the messages sent because there is little shared experiences and understanding, and unequal expectations. If these were to occur at the initial stage, how could it be possible to develop a life-long relationship?

    :)

    http://becauseimacommstudent.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. great analysis of the cute movie, UP! =)

    As mentioned: "They were thus brought together by their complementary differences , their social preference similarity and attitudinal similarity where they shared a similar social activity and had a preference for adventure."

    I too, second your thought. Because of the saying "opposites attract" and also because if both people of the exact, same character are attached, they may "fight/vie" for THAT ONE power position within the relationship.

    ReplyDelete
  5. wecritique:

    Well , I guess movies are movies and certain situations that occur are,well ,not very likely to happen but you cannot rule out that possibility either..can you.. :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Shu Ling :

    You do have a point there on the relational formation in the intial stage we look for similarities , something that both can relate to.

    Although I do not deny the fact that we find similarities,I think both come together to form that relationship and the weighting on dismilarities come out larger, at least that is what I feel. Being attracted to someone who has certain characteristics that we may not have because it may be something that we may not be able to achieve or have but having that someone allows us to sort of complete those gaps.

    Just like in the movie, (when you get a chance to watch it , I think the DVD is out) Carl was first attracted to Ellie at first due to their similar like for the adventurer. But then I think Carl was even more attracted seeing her do things that he wanted to do but did not have the courage to.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I haven't watch the movie yet but I have lots of feedback that it was really good. Maybe I will buy the dvd when it's out. Sometimes in life, it is just so strange. You get attracted to someone that is of a different character or interest from you. This reminds me of the famous saying, "unlike poles attract". I think is really true in interpersonal relationship. Maybe we are all looking for that person that is different from us, that completes us=D

    ReplyDelete